Here are three important facts that I agree to:
1. Javed Akhtar is “the” most popular lyricist in the Indian film industry today.
2. some people claim that Farhan Akhtar’s directorial skills in Dil Chahta Hai (to me it was just a plain annoying movie) were good.
3. and, some people, God spare their lives for this sin, liked Lakshya (the 3 hour ordeal where Preity Zinta, with her really bad hair wigs, and Hrithik Roshan,with his really bad hair styles, silently shape their boring lives into more boring filmy BS along with a background of what can be called, after the soundtrack of Slumdog Millioanaire, the most boring soundtrack that the film industry has ever produced).
Nothing had changed. All was fine till now.
But then came Rock on. Maybe I am just too old for all this, but I don’t see why the whole world is going crazy about Rock On?
A far as I could judge (as a die hard fan of Bollywood films, even the masala ones, Govinda ones and whatever you fling at me), the direction was awful; the dialogs were cheesy; the script looked like it was written by a high-school kid (or maybe that was the target audience of the movie); the music was boring and soporific (you can’t distinguish one song from the other), the lyrics (written by Javed Akhtar) are meaningless; Prachi Desai is/was and will always be an ordinary looking woman with no acting skills and Farhan Akhtar cannot BLOODY sing!
But what shocked me most was this- since when- since when did Indian Film industry start nominating, into singers’ category, heroes who have no voice, sense of rhythm, or tune (Farhan Akhtar)? Amir khan sang a song in Ghulaam (the song was a delightful peices and his voice has depth. He didn’t pretend to sing the song, he almost rapped it). Amitabh Bachchan’s voice is legendary in itself, but when he sang “Neela Asmaan”, his voice gave a certain blueish tinge to the song.
The “laundry ka bill” song (yeahs, that’s what I call it. I won’t deign to remember the real lyrics of the song) was neither well sung nor it had any good music/lyrics in it. Not to mention, how the raspy and out of tune song obliterated anything beautiful that the genre of rock music holds.
(Songs that have laundry in it, unless sung by Bryan Adams, cannot be accepted as legitimate lyrics. Am I the only one left with ears or what?)
But, what broke me completely was the horror of seeing “Rock On” being nominated in every major award Category in IIFA awards (I personally prefer to call them the Bachchan awards, since it’s less about excellence in cinema but more about bachchans and the young couple Ash and Abhishekh).
We are an industry that has spawned Lata Mangeshkar, Mohammad Rafi, Kishore Kumar and many other legendary singers; the new generation of singers isn’t less impressive either- shreya ghoshal, sonu nigam, udit narayan, alka yagnik, shaan…they are all such good singers. And they have worked so hard to be where they are- years of riaz and discipline and all for what- that one day, some major lyricist’s son, absolutely out of tune and with no whatsoever sense of singing and no voice, could claim a nomination right next to them?
It’s disappointing and infuriating to see Rock On being given so much of leverage. It’s a shame on the film industry. Here is a list of Indian actors, that I thought of (while doing my laundry) who are much better in their expression, voice modulation, looks, acting skills and probably singing (if they were allowed to sing like FA was) than Farhan Akhtar and are still struggling to get what Farhan Akhtar has got because of some pixie dust he got from his tooth fairy.
1. Arjun Rampal- good looking, tall, romantic, great acting, deep voice
2. Neel Nitin Mukesh- same as above
3. Jimmy Shergil- his small performance in Wednesday has left me speechless. (Aadi and I call him JCKaRV, which is Jim Carey Ka Romantic Version.
)
4. Chandrachud Singh- This guy had potential, but for some reason, he is out of the Bollywood scene)
5. Harman Baweja- so what if he copied Hritik Roshan in his first movie (Hrithik Roshan is good enough to be copied). Harman is hot, has an great voice and his dialog delivery, with a little practice, can become one of the better ones in the industry.
6. Mukul Dev- this guy, we call him Kaling Ka Senapati, not only coz of his role in Asoka, but also coz we believe that Kaling ka Senpati probably looked like Mukul Dev. Mukul Dev has that villianish thing going on. He is one of those rare gems who can look good and also instill fear in the audience.
7. Milind Soman- Hot, hot and hot! His acting in the movie 16th December was marvelous.
8. Rajeev Khandelwal- Another hottie. I am wondering, if the music were different, direction were better and dialogs and script were written by someone sensible then, with Rajeev Khandelwal, Rock on would probably have come out to be an excellent movie. He has that chocolate face thing going on for him.
9. Abhay Deol- This guy is a complete package- he is cute, he is hot, he is tall, his timing for comedy is immaculate and he acts like the industry cannot train anymore than what he already knows. He is a born actor.
10. Rahul Khanna- both khanna brothers have been major disappointments for me after Vinod Khanna. But, either their eternal bachelor status or their dimples- both of them do tend to possess some charisma.
There is no order in this list, but after seeing Wednesday, I am pretty sure Jimmy Shergil deserves to be the current heartthrob- NOT Farhan Akhtar! UGH!